Question? Just ask us!
Free Encyclopedia of Building & Environmental Inspection, Testing, Diagnosis, Repair
InspectAPedia ® Home
AGE of WATER HEATERS
ALTERNATIVE HOT WATER SOURCES
ANODES & DIP TUBES on WATER HEATERS
ANTI SCALD VALVES
APPLIANCE EFFICIENCY RATINGS
AQUASTAT CONTROL Functions
BACKDRAFTING HEATING EQUIPMENT
BACKFLOW PREVENTER, HEATER WATER FEEDER
CARBON MONOXIDE - CO
CHECK VALVES, WATER SUPPLY
CLOGGED SUPPLY PIPING
CROSS CONNECTIONS, PLUMBING
DEBRIS in WATER SUPPLY, Water Heater
DRAIN a WATER HEATER TANK
ELECTRIC WATER HEATERS
FLOODED WATER HEATER REPAIR
FREEZE-PROOF A BUILDING
GALVANIC SCALE & METAL CORROSION
GAS BURNER Flame & Noise Defects
GAS FIRED WATER HEATERS
GAS PIPING, VALVES, CONTROLS
HEATING COST SAVINGS METHODS
HOT WATER SUPPLY
HOT WATER IMPROVEMENTS
HOT WATER DELIVERY SPEED UP
HOT WATER EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT
HOT WATER PRESSURE EXPANSION RATE
HOT WATER PRESSURE LOSS
HOT WATER PROBLEM DIAGNOSIS
HOT WATER QUANTITY IMPROVEMENT
HYDROGEN SULFIDE GAS
INDIRECT FIRED WATER HEATERS
MANUALS & PARTS GUIDES - HVAC
MIXING / ANTI-SCALD VALVES
NO HEAT - NO HOT WATER: HEATER DIAGNOSIS
NOISE, WATER HEATER
ODORS IN WATER
PIPING IN buildings, Clogs Leaks Types
RELIEF VALVE LEAKS
RELIEF VALVES - Water Heaters
SCALE REMOVAL, WATER HEATERS
SEWER GAS ODORS
SOLAR HOT WATER HEATERS
TANKLESS WATER HEATERS
THERMAL EXPANSION of HOT WATER
THERMOSTATS, WATER HEATER
TIMERS for ELECTRIC WATER HEATERS
WATER HEATER ALTERNATIVES
WATER HEATER ANODES, DIP TUBES
WATER HEATER AIR INLET
WATER HEATER DEBRIS FLUSH
WATER HEATER DRAIN PROCEDURE
WATER HEATER EFFICIENCY
WATER HEATER FLUSH PROCEDURE
WATER HEATER NOISES
WATER HEATER PROBLEM DIAGNOSIS
WATER HEATER PROPERTIES
WATER HEATER SCALE
WATER HEATER SAFETY
WATER HEATERS for HOME HEATING USE?
WATER ODORS, CAUSE CURE
WATER PIPES, Clogs Leaks Types
WATER PRESSURE TOO HIGH: DANGERS
WATER PRESSURE LOSS DIAGNOSIS & REPAIR
WATER QUANTITY IMPROVEMENT
WATER SOFTENERS & CONDITIONERS
WINTERIZE A BUILDING
Early solar water heaters for making domestic hot water: in this article we describe an asbestos-insulated attic-mounted tank ultimately identified as a hot water storage tank almost certainly connected to a Day and Night Solar Water Heater or similar early solar hot water system that was widely used in California in the early 1900's. We provide photos, clue-lists, piping diagrams and sketches as well as text to help identify the types of tanks found inside old buildings.
Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2013 InspectAPedia.com, All Rights Reserved.
Photos, Pipes, Insulation, & Measurements Help Identify a Large, Antique, Insulated Steel Tank Found in an Attic: a Solar Water Heater or an Attic Cistern - water storage tank
Reader Question: Can You Identify This Old Tank in the Attic of our 1917 Home?
My wife and I purchased our 1917 home in downtown Riverside, California in 1984. In a few more years this house will be 100 years old.
To celebrate its coming birthday, I have started working on a small book about the history of the house.
When we bought the house we were told we were only the third owners, and the women we bought the house from (in her nineties) had her daughter (in her seventies) sell it to us.
The daughter told us her parents lived in the house for over fifty years and that they had not really done much to the house over all those years.
A few weeks ago the grandchildren of the second owners (in the fifties) stopped by the house from out of town to look at their grandparent’s house, which they had many fond memories of, and we invited them in for a tour.
Now that I’m starting this history project, I want to try and solve the big mystery of identifying “what the THING in my attic is.
Over the years I’ve asked a number of people: plumbers, insulating contractors, etc., but no one knows
what it is, or what it was for. It has baffled me for years.
The THING is a large wooden structure in the center of my attic right under the peak [photo above left] and goes from the attic floor all the way to the top of the roof.
structure sits on a metal trough with a 3 inch lip all the around the outside of the wooden structure, and on one side the
trough protrudes out about one foot. [See photo at left]
Two pipes are coming from where the roof meets the attic floor ( they elbow down the top of a wall I guess and maybe go down to my basement or maybe go to the water source, I really don’t know where it comes from ).
These two pipes come across the attic floor and go inside the wooden structure near the bottom.
[Photo, left depending on what is found below, these pipes probably were originally connected to a solar collector - Ed.]
Each pipe has a very old, round shutoff valve, and both pipes also have a hose bib. The valves and bib are located over the protruding trough. [Photo, above]
There are two very short, capped-off pipes on the opposite side, and a third pipe coming out has an elbow, then goes all the way to the sidewall of the attic and goes through to the outside about 10 inches and is not capped ( maybe like an overflow ).
This is near a brick chimney flue which is not for a fire place, but is a flue for the stove exhaust in the kitchen and the hot water heater in the basement.
Since I was taking photos of this THING, I decided to pry a couple of wooden boards off to see what was inside it. I took off a board near the top, and there was a heavy paper underneath.
I poked it and broke a small hole and some white powder came out. I started to pry off the board above and as I did, the whole paper tore and a lot of white powder pored out onto the floor.
This revealed the top of a galvanized cylinder tank. The tank is sitting in the middle of the structure, and has this white powder packed around it. The powder is very fine and similar to talcum powder. The tank is not open at he top, it is curved and sealed closed. The tank is about a foot in diameter.
I showed the photos to a man here in Riverside who is part of the "Old Riverside Foundation." He said he's been inside about 90% of the vintage homes in Riverside and surrounding communities and has only seen one other contraption in an attic like the one in my attic.
The other one is in a 1913 home, later purchased by William Boyd, the actor who played Hopalong Cassidy in the 1950's western television series. It is configured and constructed just like mine and the tank is packed in white powder just like mine. However this man does not really know what the tank is or what it does, and has no clue what the powder is or what its purpose is.
Do you have any idea what this THING is or was? I believe it is still tied into my plumbing? Do you have any idea what kind of powder this is and what its purpose was? I did a quick research and I don’t believe the powder is white asbestos from the pictures I’ve seen on the internet, but I don't know that for sure.
Thank you some much for taking a look at this, C.J. & B.J., Riverside CA
Take a look at and record the information listed at IDENTIFY WATER TANK USE we describe how knowing the tank size, insulation (if any, location, and piping arrangement can help to identify the original use of a storage tank found in a building. You will see from the number of pipes connected to the storage tank illustraged above that it is some type of water storage tank, probably a solar hot water tank.
It looks from the partial exposure as if the tank is in a location where people used to put expansion tanks on hot water heating boilers - instead of a relief valve, if pressure in the system got too high, water would push into the tank and if the tank got too full, water would flow out of a drain into an outdoor location, sometimes even a roof gutter or downspout.
But this tank something else. An expansion tank has just one inlet pipe that feeds water from the hot water heating system, and for attic-located expansion tanks, an overflow drain line.
Because the tank in your photographs is insulated, it's not likely to be an expansion tank and probably not an attic cistern - people didn't usually bother to insulate those containers.
If I had to guess, I'd speculate that the tank in your photos it was used to store hot water.
And arguing in support of a hot water application is the observation that your tank has so many pipes connected to it - we have talked ourselves out of the expansion tank theory entirely.
A cold water storage tank such as an attic cistern typically has a single fill pipe entering the tank, a single building supply pipe exiting the tank to deliver water to building plumbing fixtures, and possibly a third overflow pipe to handle over-filling by directing it outdoors or to a drain.
A hot water tank such as a range boiler would have water coming in from a boiler or supply, water going out to plumbing, possibly heating by gravity or convection. More pipes and connections, a least five for an attic tank:
See WATER HEATER PIPING for clues that can help explain what a tank was used for or how a solar water heater or other water heater system is installed and piped. Also see Plumbing Connections for a Range Boiler above.
Control valves may have provided for manual filling or draining of the tank. One might try arguing that the insulation was to avoid freezing, but that wouldn't explain why you saw no insulation on the pipes connected to the tank - or was it drained in winter and the system left dry?
If the tank was intended to be drained at times, for service or freeze protection, that little hose and drain pan may have been there to permit leaving the drain line open and to catch the last few drips of water from inside the tank after it was drained through its drain line (over by the chimney perhaps).
Watch out for Possible Asbestos
Watch out: while using loose-fill asbestos in powdered form would be unusual as tank insulation, I'm worried that in the installation described above someone may have poured fill asbestos around that tank to serve as insulation. If the material is firm and foam-like and pale yellow, and collapses to powder on touch it may be UFFI and not so harmful. But if this is a white, loose, dry powder, watch out - seal it off with plastic until we know what you're dealing with. Hopefully it's something else.
Obtain advice from an expert, or in an emergency, clean up a tiny spill with a HEPA vacuum, and don't track this material through the house, or you may create a more costly cleanup job.
UFFI was blown in to building walls during the energy worries of the 1970's oil embargo. Your antique attic tank installation with the paper and pit-saw cut boards (FRAMING MATERIALS, Age, Types) looks much older, probably from the time of original construction of the home back in 1917.
Guessing at the Original Use of An Attic-Mounted Hot Water Tank - Solar Water Heater Hot Water Storage?
A first guess considering size, location, and insulation is that the tank was for storing hot water from a boiler or some hot water source for example, feeding hot water down into the house by gravity and perhaps heating the water in the tank by natural convection to and from a basement boiler or even a separate water heater that could even have been down in the basement. If you can give me tank dimensions (and don't have an asbestos problem) that'd be helpful.
We need to look more closely at where piping comes and goes.
Watch out: if the covering boards were removed (DONT MESS before we know the asbestos question) you'd find hat those four pipes are connected to different heights on the tank.
It's unusual in my experience to put a range boiler in an attic, so remote from the heating boiler, but someone may have done so thinking that they would get better hot water delivery pressure in the home.
And I'd like to know the full measurements of the tank or if you leave it boxed in pending the asbestos question, just the dimensions of the wooden framed box would help.
Keep me posted on the asbestos worry and about to where you can trace piping - that asbestos question is a priority concern.
Ultimately, with reader help we were able to identify the most likely purpose of the water storage tank described above. Key in understanding the tank's design and use was an examination of its piping connections.
Day and Night Solar Water Heater - early solar water heating design
Reader comment: If you can find a copy of the book A Golden Thread, it will help. I've attached a scan of a page that shows how the "Day and Night Solar Water Heater" was installed. Good chance that's what you have. Yours, Larry Weingarten - 8/20/2013
The text in Mr. Weingarten's attachment identifies what may indeed be the rest of the system that used the tank shown in the illustrations above. Larry can be reached through WaterHeaterRescue.com.
Reader Follow-Up: Riverside CA tank was used for attic water storage, gypsum "insulation"
I have received information from historians here in Riverside who are aware of what my "mystery" plumbing tank in my attic is. It turns out there are 3 or 4 other older homes in Riverside that have the same plumbed tank in the attic. One of the houses is a famous house which was owned by the actor William Boyd who played Hopalond Cassidy on TV in the early fifties.
The Riverside historians explained that when my house was built in 1916, Riverside's municipal water district was brand new and water pressure was very unreliable. A handful of builders included an optional luxury for a few homes consisting of a water storage tank in the attic. City water came into the house and went straight to the tank in the attic, filled the tank, then continued down to the bathrooms, kitchen and hose bibs. Then on days when the water pressure was bad or nonexistent, the water in the tank would gravity flow for normal continued use.
Also, I had the white powder packed around the tank tested and it wasn't asbestos, it was gypsum. Thanks for all the help and interest, C.J. - Riverside CA 10/8/2013
Reply: sorting out antique solar hot water from antique attic cold water storage
Wow, what good news, and thanks for the feedback; I'll be sure to update the online information; Indeed while asbestos was widely used as an insulation material in buildings, in that use it was typically as asbestos paper, cloth, or lagging on pipe elbows; only in a few odd cases have we found loose asbestos insulation in homes - but it was indeed better to be safe than sorry, as such dust, had it been asbestos, could have led to a costly mess.
In fact the gypsum was perhaps considered also an insulating material, maybe to avoid condensation on the tank. So glad it worked out.
The general design of a backup water storage tank for use in areas where municipal water supply is inconsistent is indeed widespread and still common around the world.
You can see this in our rooftop water storage tanks (photo above) in wide use throughout Mexico, shown at ROOFTOP WATER TANKS.
What remains puzzling was what appeared in the photos to be more water pipes than would be needed for just an attic cistern. The multiple pipe connections along with the history of early solar water heaters in Riverside CA led me in the guess direction I described above.
Could you make a sketch for me of the pipes you observed connected to this device? Perhaps there were not as many connections as I first thought.
Also can we ge the dimensions of the tank; generally a cold water storage tank might be expected to be quite a bit larger than a hot water storage tank or water heater tank of any sort.
On the other hand, as I show at left, I have found an occasional very small attic "cistern" such as this one (above left) from a historic home in New England.
Green link shows where you are in this article series.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
No FAQs have been posted for this page. Try the search box below or CONTACT US by email if you cannot find the answer you need at InspectApedia.
Questions & answers or comments about installing, using, & repairing range boilers used for hot water supply in buildings.
Ask a Question or Enter Search Terms in the InspectApedia search box just below.
Technical Reviewers & References
Related Topics, found near the top of this page suggest articles closely related to this one.