Home test kit for lead (C) Daniel Friedman

Home Test Kit for Lead on Building Surfaces - Test Kit Review
     


InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

Here we demonstrate and review the performance of an over-the-counter home test kit for lead. We describe simple procedures we used to confirm that a home lead test kit was actually working reliably. We describe the lead test kit contents and we illustrate how the kit is used.

. Also see Lead Contamination in Drinking Water: Testing & Correction - Advice. Our photo at page top shows the contents of the Pro-Lab® home test kit for lead on building surfaces.

Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2015 InspectApedia.com, All Rights Reserved.

Lead Testing Kit for Home Use

We purchased a readily-available home test kit for lead on building surfaces and followed the kit instructions. Home test kits for lead on surfaces include a treated wiping pad that is wiped across the test surface. A change in color (to red or pink) will in normal circumstances indicate the presence of lead that can be released by touch or by placing food on such a surface. The same company, ProLab®, provides other home test kits including a test for lead in water - a service that is widely available including from local health departments and from private water testing laboratories.

Photograph of old paint on a historic building, paint is likely to be a source of lead contamination on the soils below.Wipe type lead test kits are suitable for testing a variety of surfaces including

  • Painted building surfaces such as the Colonial era home shown at left
  • Painted or other children's toys
  • Glazed ceramic dishes
  • Lead crystal glassware
  • Soil (dirt)
  • Pipe surfaces to confirm lead piping (not really necessary as you can determine this by visual inspection in most cases)
  • Many other surfaces. Special steps are needed when testing red-painted surfaces in order to assure that red pigment is not confounding the test and giving a false indication of the presence of lead. Additional steps are needed when testing painted surfaces: the painted surface is notched to expose the inner layers of paint and the test pad is held applied to that surface for the duration of the test interval.

What the Home Test Kit for Lead Contains

Home test kit for lead (C) Daniel FriedmanWe purchased a ProLab® Lead Surface Test Kit from a local building supply store for $9.98 plus tax and brought it to our forensic lab. Our photo (left) shows the contents of the lead surface test kit. ProLab's brochure notes that this lead surface wipe test kit can detect lead levels down to 5 parts per million - 5ppm.

The test kit is sealed in a plastic pack, perhaps to assure that the contents are kept clean, uncontaminated, and to protect from pilferage in the store. The lead surface test kit package promises that the kit contains six tests. Here is what our kit included:

  • Instructions for conducting the lead surface test - the inner surfaces of the lead surface test kit paper cover contains clear, easy to follow instructions. Don't throw this paper away. Read it.
  • A plastic eye dropper that you'll use to place four drops of water onto your test pad. We used tap water as the instructions didn't specify that distilled or otherwise guaranteed lead-free water be used for this procedure.
  • A plastic bag containing two paper lead test wipes that provide for up to six lead surface tests. If you read the instructions carefully (as we failed to do) you'll see that these two pads, each a bit over an inch long, are to be cut into three pieces to yield a total of six lead surface wipe tests.
  • A product brochure advertising other ProLab® test kit products.

Lead Test Kit Experimental Design

We purchased our lead surface wipe test kit at a local building supply store. We read and followed the kit's instructions carefully. We performed two tests:

  1. Testing a known lead-contaminated surface: We tried the lead surface test kit on the surface of an antique Mexican ceramic dish known to contain lead glazing.

    We followed this simple low-tech lead test kit performance test with a second step to check for false positives - indicating lead where it is absent.

  2. Testing a surface known not to contain lead: As a control, we tried out the lead test surface kit on the surface of a modern ceramic plate known to be lead-free.

Below we describe the steps in the lead test kit procedure as well as the results of these simple experiments.

Steps in Testing a Surface for Lead Contamination

Lead containing ceramic platter (C) Daniel Friedman Lead containing ceramic platter (C) Daniel Friedman

We washed and dried our test surface, an antique Mexican platter (photos above) whose glazing was reported by the seller as containing lead. We didn't want any possible food, debris, or other residue to contaminate our test surface.

Obviously if you're testing a building wall you won't have to power-wash the wall. But if testing an outdoor surface that is dirty you'll want to remove that surface dirt first too.

Incidentally, modern ceramic ware as well as other consumer products purchased in Mexico are made from lead-free materials - the hazards of lead poisoning are widely recognized. Start by asking your vendor if you have any question about the use of lead in the product. Finish by testing products for lead if there is any doubt about their condition.

Lead surface test in process (C) Daniel Friedman

We collected our test platter, an egg timer (the instructions say to wipe the pad on the test surface slowly for two minutes), our eyedropper and a glass of clean tap water.

We dripped four drops of clean water onto the test pad (photo at left) as it sat on our test surface, then we wiped slowly over most of the platter surface for the required two minutes.

We inspected our test pad for a color change at the end of this time.

Results of Surface Test for Lead Contamination

Lead surface test results (C) Daniel Friedman

The test pad turned pink, indicating that the platter glaze contains lead.

We won't use this antique platter for food.

Next we also conducted a pigment-leaching test (described below) recommended by ProLab® to make sure that none of the red glazing was itself leaching red pigment onto our lead surface test pad. Pigment leaching could give a false positive for lead contamination.

Testing the Surface for Red Pigment Leaching

Red Pigment Test for Lead (C) Daniel Friedman Red Pigment Test for Lead (C) Daniel Friedman

The ProLab® lead surface test kit instructions recommend testing red pigmented surfaces to be sure that the test is not falsely indicating the presence of lead (the pad turns red or pink) when what is really happening is that the test is picking up red pigment from the test surface. This is a likely hazard with red painted surfaces and is less likely with ceramics, but we performed this check anyway.

Our photo (above left) shows our clean cotton swab moistened with distilled white vinegar being applied to a red area of our lead-positive ceramic platter. Our photo of the swab at the end of our test (above right) shows that no red pigment was picked up by the swab. This result confirms that our earlier test that indicated the presence of lead was accurate and that it was not confounded by removable red pigment from the test surface.

Our Q-tip shows that no red color was lifted during our test of the red portions of surface of our test platter.

Steps in Testing a Control Surface for Absence of Lead Contamination

Lead surface wipe control test (C) Daniel Friedman

We performed this second lead surface wipe test as a control to confirm that the home test kit for lead would not indicate the presence of lead contamination (by mistake) on a surface that is lead-free.

We repeated the two minute surface wipe of our control surface.

If we had not already been pretty sure that our platter contained lead, we would have added a third test for lead on a second known-lead-containing surface as well.

But our particular home test kit contained only two tests - see What the Home Test Kit for Lead Contains, above.

Results of Control Test on a Known No-Lead Surface

After the required two minutes of slow wiping of the test plate surface with our second test pad moistened with four drops of water from the same water source, the lead surface test wipe pad remained plain white - there was no color change. This indicated that no lead was detected on the surface of our control plate, and it confirmed that the tests appeared to be working normally.

We could have cut our first test wipe pad in half to be extra cautious in this procedure, testing half on each of the two plates. That would have reduced the chances of an effect of variation in chemical treatment between our two test pads.

Conclusions Regarding the ProLab Lead Surface Wipe Test

ProLab® has provided an easy, reliable lead surface test: The ProLab® lead surface test kit was easy to use, quick, and appeared to be accurate and reliable.

Lead paint on an old building (C) Daniel FriedmanFragile test wipe pads: We noticed, however, that the paper test wipe pads disintegrate easily. Our photo at Results of Surface Test for Lead Contamination, above, shows some pilling and rolling up of paper fragments on the test wipe.

This might be one of the reasons why the manufacturer emphasizes to wipe the lead test surface slowly. But the fragility of these paper wipes mean that it would be difficult to wipe a rough, alligatored painted surface on a building (photo at left) for the full two minutes.

For a rough surface such as that in our photo (left) you may be able to complete the test by simply holding the moistened test pad on the surface for two minutes, or make the notched surface cut recommended in the instructions before holding the test pad on the surface.

Wash the ceramic surface: If testing a surface that might be contaminated with other materials you might want to gently wash or clean it first to be sure you're not confusing your test by extraneous chemicals.

Test for red pigment release before testing for lead: because the lead wipe test may leave a thin coating of residue of red (lead positive) test chemical on the tested surface, if you are going to perform the red pigment release test, either do this test before you test for lead with the wipe, or be sure to wash any test chemical residue off of the surface before testing for red pigment. Otherwise red (lead positive) chemical may show up on your cotton swab and it may be mistaken for released pigment.

Remember to wash off the vinegar. If your test surface is dishware or a toy or similar item, you also will want to wash off the lead test chemical residue after using the moistened lead surface wiping pad.

...




Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Click to Show or Hide FAQs

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Questions & answers on buying and using lead paint test kits in homes, including how to assess the reliablity of home test kits for lead contamination on surfaces and in settled dust

Use the "Click to Show or Hide FAQs" link just above to see recently-posted questions, comments, replies, try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

HTML Comment Box is loading comments...

Technical Reviewers & References

Publisher's Google+ Page by Daniel Friedman

Click to Show or Hide Citations & References