Leaky Heating Oil Tanks - How Oil Tanks are Tested for Evidence Leaks, of Current or Previous Oil Spills InspectAPedia® -
Oil tank testing method choices: pressure testing, oil tank sonogram testing, oil tank leak soil tests
Soil testing for oil tank leaks & Oil tank pressure testing for oil tank leaks
Oil tank fill pressures - to what pressure is an oil tank subjected during an oil delivery?
Simple tests for water in oil tanks
Electronic oil tank leak scanning & ground scanning radar for hidden oil tank location
Our site offers impartial, unbiased advice without conflicts of interest.
We will block advertisements which we discover or readers inform us are associated with bad business practices,
false-advertising, or junk science. Our contact info is at
InspectAPedia.com/appointment.htm.
This document describes the common methods used to test oil storage tanks for evidence of
leakage, either by soil testing, pressure testing of the tank, or by other tank screening measurements.
Other steps to locate and test heating oil storage tanks at properties, both buried tanks and above ground tanks
are discussed at other documents at this website. Readers should also see OIL TANK LEAK ADVICE and OIL TANK LEAK CAUSES.
Leaking oil tanks are not only a concern as contaminants of the water supply, but
have become an increasing general
environmental concern addressed by the DEC. Leaking commercial equipment and
even simply-suspect equipment have been extremely costly to address. Such
burdens were never anticipated when the equipment was installed. While similar
regulations pertaining to residential installations are scarce, this topic is
of growing concern to home owners and home
buyers.
TANK TESTING - How Oil Tanks are Tested for Evidence of Leakage
Specialists and some oil companies have equipment to test buried tanks for
leaks. Both simple pressure-testing and sophisticated electronic testing are
used, mostly on commercial equipment, and more recently on residential tanks.
Testing for water in the tank is simple and can be done by any service person
using a simple chemical paste on a probe. A lot of water in the tank is a reason
to be pessimistic about its condition.
There are a number of tank testing methods currently in use, varying in risk to
the tank, cost, invasiveness, length of time to complete, and some, requiring
shutting down of the heating system during test period. See "How do you
choose the right tank testing method?" Cynthia Johnson, Fuel Oil & Oil
Heat Magazine, November 1995.
Low-psi oil tank pressure-testing for leaks is used to test a tank for existing leaks.
Soil testing for oil tank leaks looks for evidence of actual oil contamination in the soil. A proper soil
test is based on having located the buried tank or the site where a tank was buried, and taking
borings to a depth approximately just below the tank bottom.
Electronic testing of oil tanks to check for leak scan also screen tanks for evidence of damage - usually this was used only on commercial jobs
Oil tank ultrasound screening program (photo above) is offered by some oil companies who scan the bottom section of above ground oil tanks to measure the thickness of the tank steel. Tanks that pass an ultrasound screening test may be insured against future leakage.
The oil company technician uses an ultrasound scanner to make twelve thickness measurements on the lower portion of the oil tank and records the thickness at each location. Typical oil tank thickness readings on an older above-ground indoor oil tank may range from 0.105 to 0.185 inches in thickness.
If all 12 sample point thicknesses exceed 0.100" the oil tank "passes" and the dealer offers $1000. insurance for a year as part of the fee. Our photo (above) shows an oil tank sonogram in process for the author, conducted by Nash Brothers Oil Company, Hyde Park, NY.
Water testing in oil tanks can indicate the risk of in-tank corrosion and thus leakage - an easy first-pass which
can be used at both above ground tanks and buried oil tanks
Ground scanning radar or magnetic sensing is also used to locate buried steel tanks.
PRESSURE TESTING - Oil Tank Pressure Testing Advice
Using this tank testing method the oil tank is sealed and pressurized to a low psi level, then
carefully monitored for a pressure drop, perhaps for 24 hours. This method is comparatively
quick to execute but I don't care for it. Notice (in our photo at left) that some oil tank manufacturers do not want their oil tanks pressure-tested after the tank has been installed. Details are at OIL TANK PRESSURE.
First, if there is a pressure drop, additional testing
will be required to determine if there has been actual oil seepage into the soil. (A leak could have been
a minor one at the tank top, for example.) The additional testing is pretty-much the same as
my second method described below, so the consumer ends up paying for testing twice in this case.
Second, even if there is not a pressure drop, I'm not sure that there hasn't been a tank
leak in the past, perhaps fixed by a plumbing repair or other method.
Some home owners balk at this test, fearing that the pressure of the test procedure will "burst" an oil
tank that is about to fail. I am doubtful that this is a legitimate concern. The pressure at which the tank
is being tested is almost certainly a much lower psi than the pressure to which the tank is subjected
while it is being filled by the oil delivery truck and driver.
SOIL TESTING - Soil Tests for evidence of tank leakage
We prefer this method for testing for evidence of leaks at buried oil tanks. The cost for soil testing is about the same
as the first method where buried tanks are installed.
Multiple soil borings are collected around the tank, at a depth just past the
level of the tank bottom. The soil samples are tested for petroleum product contamination.
This is
considered the definitive test for oil tank leakage, and if the tank has not leaked, it provides more reliable documentation of
that fact. More time is needed to complete the test as there is a delay for the lab work.
Consider that if you opted for the tank pressure test described earlier, and if the test showed that the tank
has leaked oil into its surrounding soil, some additional testing is going to be needed to confirm the extent of
soil contamination. It seems to me it's better to test the soil in the first place, thus also covering not only current but past conditions.
Finally, if we are told that an oil tank has been "remove" or "abandoned" at a property, we expect to be given the
documentation that outlines who did what when, and importantly, what steps were taken to assure that there was no oil leak that was
simply left for the next owner to discover and clean-up. If adequate documentation is not provided, a soil test is certainly appropriate. One
of my clients took this advice and discovered, and avoided having to pay for, a $60,000. site cleanup at the property he was buying.
TEST FOR WATER - Test oil tanks for presence of water
Buried tanks, such as heating oil tanks, should be tested for amount of water
present in tank bottom, and water should be pumped out. Even above-ground tanks can take on large amounts of water from roof spillage, condensation, or a bad oil delivery. (Photo at left).
In fact, water can
accumulate in indoor or outdoor above ground oil storage tanks too, either from exposure to varying
temperatures (in-tank condensation) or from the occasional
delivery of bad oil which contains excessive water content.
A neat way to look for a history of water in the heating oil storage tank is to check the
oil filter canister itself. Many oil burners are protected by a heating oil filter
installed either at the tank or at the oil burner. (Every heating boiler burning oil
shouldhave one of these filters installed to protect the equipment.)
If the oil tank has a high level of water, especially if the oil lines run to the oil burner from
the bottom of the oil tank, some of that water will have been making its way to
the oil burner where, en route, it is (usually) trapped in the oil filter. If you open an oil
filter container and see that its metal parts are rusted, or that there is a lot of rusty sludge
in the bottom of the filter holding canister, the oil tank needs to be checked further for water
The oil service technician can check the level of water in an oil tank by putting some "oil finder paste" on the
bottom of a stick or probe which is inserted into the tank and to its bottom. The paste changes color in the presence
of water, showing, by the length of color change on the probe, the depth of water in the bottom of the tank. Obviously this
trick is much easier if the tank is outside than indoors where a basement ceiling can make probing the oil tank difficult.
Ask your oil service company to perform this test.
While we've found them
lasting longer, a common life expectancy of buried oil tanks is 10-15 years. We
do not have the same data for gas tanks. Life may be similar.
If the tank is to
remain in use, ask your fuel supplier about using an additive
or other methods to help remove water. Warning: on some older oil tanks which had a lot
of sludge in the tank, as the de-watering additive (such as "4-in-1-HOT (TM)") was added to the
tank we found an increase in the debris making its way to the heating oil filter. You should inspect
the filter cartridge for water and debris and have it changed more frequently until this question
is closed. It's more trouble but the end result is a more reliable oil storage tank and heating system.
Critique, contributions wanted: Contact Us to suggest corrections or additions to articles at this website, and if you wish, to receive online listing and credit as a contributor. Particular thanks are due to the many experts and also consumers who read and critique technical articles at InspectAPedia.com.
Additional technical contributors & reference sources for this article are listed below.
Use links just below or at the left of each page to navigate this document or to view other topics at this website. Green links show where you are in our document or website.
Yamada Pumps, 800 990-7867, is a leading producer of
industrial equipment since 1905, and of fluid handling products
for over 60 years. Yamada America supports pump requirements for North, Central, and South America and has an assembly facility in the U.S. in Arlington Heights, IL. Special thanks to David Hollen, Applications & Technical Support, 847 631-9200 ext. 218, for technical consulting regarding pump selection and capacity.
Boyles Law: this simple gas law explains the relation between pressure and volume when either of those changes - P1 • V1 = P2 • V2 A nice online calculator for Boyles Law simple pressure and volume change operations is provided by 1728 Software Systems and can be found online at www.1728.com/boyle.htm
"Chapter 2, Operating Your Heating Oil Tank", Main Department of Environmental Protection, maine.gov/dep/rwm/ust/pdf/hotdoc2.pdf and see maine.gov/dep/rwm/ust/ for Maine's basic guide to oil storage tanks and maine.gov/dep/rwm/ust/statutesrules.htm for Maine's UST stautes and rules.
Nash Brothers Oil Company, located in Hyde Park, NY, (845) 229-8695, offers oil delivery and oil heating services in the New York Hudson Valley area.
OIL TANK REGULATIONS lists oil tank regulations for all U.S. states and protectorates as well as Federal and some Canadian authorities on oil tank regulation and leak reporting
See WATER in OIL TANKS for added
suggestions for finding and removing water from oil storage tanks.
A discussion of methods for finding evidence of previous or current buried tanks
at properties is at BURIED OIL TANKS, FINDING
More detail about the chances that an oil tank is leaking or about to leak is at
TANK FAILURE RATES.
More detail about the causes of oil tank leaks, both buried and above ground tanks,
is at OIL TANK FAILURE CAUSES.
Regulations governing tank leak reporting and tank abandonment as well as the registration
of oil tanks at properties is at OIL TANK REGULATIONS
More Information on Building Diagnostic Inspections and Repairs
Oil Tanks - The Oil Storage Tank Information Website: Buried or Above Ground Oil Tank Inspection, Testing, Cleanup, Abandonment of Oil Tanks
Abandon a Buried Oil Tank, How To - Abandoning Commercial Underground Tanks, Russ Brauksieck, ASHI Tech. Journal, Vol.3 No.1 Spring 1993, P. 40-41 [Reprint]
Petroleum Bulk Storage J. Sibblies, NY State DEC, Advice to Home Owners and Home Inspectors about Oil Storage Tanks - summary from ASHI Chapter Seminar.
Septic Tank inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair
OIL TANK FAILURE CAUSES - Oil Tank Failure Causes - oil tank leaks are caused by corrosion, damage, soil conditions, other factors
OIL TANK TESTING - How Oil Tanks are Tested for Evidence Leaks, of Current or Previous Oil Spills
TANK FAILURE RATES - Oil Tank Failure Rates - Oil Tank Leak Probability as a Function of Tank Age, Location, Condition, Soil Conditions and Other Factors
Web Link Exchange: Contact Us to list your website or contact information for oil tank testing, tank corrosion research, oil industry experts
InspectAPedia® Home & Site Map - Building & Environmental Inspection, Testing, Diagnosis, Repair, & Problem Prevention Advice: In-depth research & advice on diagnosing, testing, correcting, & preventing building defects & indoor environmental hazards. Unbiased information, no conflicts of interest.
The Mold Information Center: What to Do About Mold in Buildings, When and How to Inspect for Mold, Clean Up Mold, or Avoid Mold Problems
Environmental Inspection, Testing, & Diagnosis On-Site IAQ, Gas, Air Testing, Mold Investigation, Sick Building Diagnosis, Lab Services, & Remediation Plan Preparation - indoor air quality testing, problem source determination, supporting lab work, written remediation plan addressing removal of environmental and other hazards and prevention of their recurrence.